At Jacob Sunrooms, Exteriors & Baths, we’ve helped thousands of St. Louis homeowners create spaces they lovestepping into each morning. And when it comes to bathroom remodeling, one of the biggest questions people face is: Should I go with a bathtub or a shower?
While there’s no one-size-fits-all answer, we’re here to walk you through the real considerations—not just trends or cookie-cutter advice. Whether you're in the early planning phase or ready to dive into a renovation, this guide will help you decide what fits your lifestyle, space, and future plans.
Why homeowners choose a shower:
- Quick and easy: Perfect for fast-paced mornings or limited schedules.
- Better for smaller bathrooms: Walk-in showers create an open, modern feel.
- Accessibility: Great option for aging in place or anyone with mobility needs.
- Effortless to clean: Fewer curves and crevices mean less maintenance.
At Jacob, we often install low-threshold walk-in showers with built-in seating, grab bars, and stylish acrylic finishes—so functionality never has to mean sacrificing design.
Is a shower right for you?
If your bathroom’s your reset zone and you're all about efficiency meets style, a walk-in shower might be your ideal upgrade.
Why homeowners keep the tub:
- Relaxation central: There’s nothing quite like soaking stress away in a warm bath.
- Perfect for families: Kids (and even some pets) are easier to bathe in a tub.
- Resale value: Many buyers expect at least one tub in the home.
- Multi-functionality: Combine with a showerhead for flexibility.
We’ve worked with families across the Metro East and Greater St. Louis area who want to keep the tub—but modernize the space. Our acrylic tub systems are built for durability, easy maintenance, and fast installs (sometimes in as little as one day).
Is a bathtub right for you?
If comfort is king in your home and you love the idea of a long soak or need to accommodate little ones, a tub might be your perfect match.
What Homeowners Are Asking
We recently helped a homeowner in O’Fallon, IL who was torn between a tub and shower. Their kids were out of the house, they never used the tub, and accessibility was a growing concern. We replaced their outdated combo unit with a sleek, walk-in shower with grab bars and a built-in bench—and they told us they wished they’d done it years ago.
These are the kinds of lifestyle-based decisions we walk through every day. It’s never about what’s trendy—it’s about what works for you.
How to Decide: Key Questions to Ask Yourself
✅ Do you take more showers or baths?
✅ How long do you plan to live in the home?
✅ Are there kids or aging family members in the household?
✅ What’s the size and layout of your bathroom?
✅ Do you want luxury, function—or both?
It’s About Your Space, Your Style, Your Life
A bathroom remodel isn’t just about new fixtures—it’s about upgrading the way you live. At Jacob Sunrooms, Exteriors & Baths, we approach every remodel with a simple goal: build something that makes your day-to-day better.
Not sure which is right for you? That’s okay. Schedule a free consultation, and we’ll help you explore the best-fit solution with no pressure—just straight answers from a local team that’s been trusted for over 40 years.
FAQs: Bathtub vs. Shower
1. Is a shower or tub better for resale value?
That depends on your market. Many buyers prefer at least one tub in the home, especially families. However, a beautiful, accessible shower can boost appeal too—especially in a master suite.
2. Can I install a walk-in shower in a small bathroom?
Absolutely. Walk-in showers can actually make small bathrooms feel more open and modern. We offer custom sizes to fit almost any space.
3. What if I want both a tub and a shower?
Combo units are still a great option, and we offer modern, easy-to-clean tub-shower combinations that offer the best of both worlds.
4. How long does installation take?
Many of our bathtub and shower projects can be completed in as little as one day, depending on your space and selection.
5. How do I choose the right materials?
We’ll walk you through everything—colors, textures, accessories—during your design consultation. All of our materials are chosen for durability and low maintenance.
Ready to take the next step?
Explore your options at jacobsunroom.com/bathroom-remodeling or give us a call to schedule your free quote. We're here to make your vision real—with expert craftsmanship, honest advice, and unmatched service.
